Survivor 23: Episode 3: Reap What You Sow

TRIBAL COUNCIL Cochran starts off Tribal Council by noting his contribution in today’s challenge as one of the operators of the winch. Papa Bear counters by saying that Cochran is a physical threat to himself. In response to Jeff’s question on leadership, Cochran claims Ozzy is the leader. Papa Bear admits that he usually likes to be a leader, but he has nothing in common with the five-person alliance, which is in control of this tribe. The subject of an idol comes up next. Ozzy admits being burned in a past season, by not playing an immunity idol and therefore being voted out. Cochran brings up the point that you have to be careful of how the tribe perceives you when you search for an individual idol. The tribe can see you as being suspicious and untrustworthy, if you focus too much on the idol. It's time for the tribe to vote. Papa Bear receives six votes, while Cochran and Jim both receive one vote each. So, Mark "Papa Bear” Caruso, the 48 year-old retired NYPD detective from Forest Hills, N.Y. becomes the third person voted out of SURVIVOR: SOUTH PACIFIC and sent to Redemption Island. 

ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Every season when I talk to the contestants before the game starts they go on about all these things that they are not going to reveal to the other players. And then they get out there and can’t help themselves. The latest example was Brandon telling his entire tribe about being Russell’s nephew, which he promised he wouldn’t do. Why can’t these people zip their lips? Is it a lack of discipline? And seeing as how people seem to have such a hard time keeping secrets about themselves, do you think contestants are better off just telling the truth from the get-go as opposed to having to come clean or get caught in a lie later?

JEFF PROBST: I think the answer to this question is the reason reality works in general – people want to talk about themselves. Whenever this topic comes up in casting and someone says “I’m not gonna tell anybody I’m a doctor,” I immediately say, “You won’t be able to help yourself.” People just want to talk and they want to share who they are and their accomplishments. In Brandon’s case, the guy is just so conflicted he doesn’t know what to do and as a result he’s reacting rather than acting and everybody sees it. It’s killing his game right now but it’s making him a candidate to take to the end because I don’t think he can win…at this point, anyway.

EW: Semhar is the first person to exit the game, as you predicted before the season started. (Good call!) So now I’m going to put you on the spot: Which contestant from which season were you most sorry to see go out first? (My vote goes to Francesca from Redemption Island.) 

JP: Hmm good question.. and good guess as to my answer, but you’re wrong!  I did like Francesca and would actually like to see her back on the show, but my biggest disappointment was seeing Jessica DeBen from Survivor: Fiji being voted off first. I really liked her style. She’s attractive, she seemed to have a good sense of herself. Then again, maybe it was better for her that she was voted off. Maybe she was too normal.

EW: Do you ever want to exercise any sort of veto power over self-appointed nicknames? For example, I have to imagine you felt a tad awkward having to say, “Papa Bear, the tribe has spoken.”

JP: Dalton, you’re a funny dude and pretty aware. I think Papa Bear was the toughest of all the nicknames we’ve had on the show. Something about it just felt slightly wrong, or like I was saying something that was not quite appropriate for Survivor. Ask me this question at the end of next season, you may get a different answer.

EW: Don’t you dare go anywhere until you tease us up good for next week! 

JP: We revisit a classic challenge and at least one Survivor has a chance to break a record set years ago by Rupert “America’s Choice” Boneham.

Savaii			Upolu
"Papa Bear" -	Karen D.		Sophie ---	Pat
"Cochran"---	Brendan		Albert ----	Steve
Whitney ------	Cara		Brandon --	Brandon
"Ozzy" -------	Christianne		Edna ------	Karen R.
Dawn ----------	Kim		Rick -------	Colin
Jim ------------	Lauren		Stacey ----	Erin
Keith ----------	Dick		Christine-	Warren
Elyse ----------	Cheryl		"Coach" -	Tonya
			Mikayla --	Sandy